By Lynn Jensen
In a decision on April 11th, the Board of Supervisors voted 3-2 to remove newly nominated Commissioner Bruce Smith from the Ventura County Planning Commission. The Smith appointment by Supervisor Steve Bennett was initially approved at a February Board hearing where Supervisor’s Peter Foy and Kelly Long were absent. Smith is a 35 year veteran of the Ventura County Planning Division who retired as the manager of long-range planning.
After learning of the appointment during his absence, Supervisor Foy questioned whether it was appropriate for a veteran insider in the Planning Division to become a Planning Commissioner representing the area he used to manage. He also clearly stated that his concerns were not with Mr. Smith personally.
Supervisor Foy quoted the Planning Commission Handbook in his letter to the Board of Supervisors: “The Ventura County Planning Commission Handbook states, “Planning Commissioners are appointees who do not necessarily have a background in planning or related areas, but may have had some relevant experience.” It goes on to say, “The philosophy behind the relationship of the Commission and the Planning Division staff is that the staff provides legal, technical and professional information and evaluations, but the Planning Commission adds to the staff recommendations the view of the ordinary citizen as to how the County will be developed and maintained.”
To rally support for the Smith appointment, Supervisor Bennett sent out an email to his supporters claiming that the opposition to the Smith appointment was about weakening SOAR. Apparently Mr. Smith was an avid supporter of SOAR and collected signatures for the 2016 ballot measures.
In comments to Kathleen Wilson of the Ventura County Star, Supervisor Bennett claimed that “powerful enemies” and “anti-SOAR” forces were orchestrating a campaign against his appointment and named CoLAB as the opposition.
It is not the first time Supervisor Bennett has made false accusations about CoLAB to his followers and the media, but this was too blatant for us to ignore. We believe the Star needs to be sure that “powerful” supervisors are held accountable, not allowing them to make unchecked false accusations and being sure to invite those targeted to comment.
In response to Kathleen Wilson’s article, we sent a “Letter to the Editor” to set the record straight. Below we included a link to the original Star article and our response letter for your viewing:
False Accusations by Supervisor
Re: your story April 11, “Planning commissioner opposed“:
In an email alert to his followers, Supervisor Steve Bennett made several false claims and accusations in defense of Bruce Smith, his appointee to the Ventura County Planning Commission.
The email wrongly blamed CoLAB and SOAR opponents for a board agenda item seeking to remove Smith from the commission. In comments to The Star, Mr. Bennett denounced the “powerful enemies” behind the effort to remove Smith and named CoLAB as being among them. The Star printed these comments without contacting CoLAB for a response. In fact, CoLAB was surprised by the agenda item and took no position at the Board of Supervisors hearing.
Supervisor Peter Foy objected to the appointment of a 35 year veteran and manager in the Planning Division to the Planning Commission, an argument Bennett claimed in his email was “meritless.” However, two of his fellow supervisors found merit in Foy’s arguments and voted to remove Smith from the commission. This included Supervisor Linda Parks, who is a SOAR board member.
Bennett claimed that without Smith on the Planning Commission, SOAR would somehow be watered down in the county general plan. This is patently false. The language of the SOAR initiative will be added word for word to the updated general plan. Nothing can be changed until 2050 without a vote of the people.
In review, CoLAB believes supervisors Foy, Parks and Kelly Long got this one right. Ironically, Bennett’s supporters testifying for the Smith appointment included other retired managers from the Planning Division. Filling the commission with lifelong regulators would obliterate the purpose stated in the Planning Commission Handbook to add “the view of the ordinary citizen” to the planning process. We thank Supervisor Foy for his leadership and vision on this issue.
Editor: The author is executive director of the Ventura County Coalition of Labor, Agriculture and Business (CoLAB).
Lynn Gray Jensen, Camarillo